Nvidia Shield 4K vs Apple TV 4K: the best 4K boxes compared It's Android TV head to head against Apple TV

by ShawnDex

"If you're looking for a box to get 4K video content and a host of other goodness up on a television screen, then the Nvidia Shield 4K and Apple TV 4K are two of the devices at the front of the queue – but at the end of the day which is better at serving up your media?

We're here to help you make sense of the pros and cons of these two boxes: we're going to put them head-to-head in all the categories that matter, from the design of the hardware to the supported apps. Read on for our full Nvidia Shield 4K vs Apple TV 4K breakdown.

Nvidia Shield 4K vs Apple TV 4K: design

If you've got a box that's competently serving up 4K video to your big screen display, does it matter what the actual box looks like? Well, maybe. If you're wanting your home cinema setup to be as aesthetically pleasing as possible, then you're going to be interested in the design and stylings of the Nvidia Shield 4K and the Apple TV 4K.

The Nvidia Shield 4K is definitely the more striking device, design-wise. It's also flatter, and wider – measuring 159 mm x 98 mm x 25.93 mm (6.26 in x 3.86 in x 1.02 in), the Nvidia Shield 4K weighs in at 250 g (8.8 oz). We like the distinctive green flash on the top of the box that glows green when the unit is up and running too.

As for the Apple TV 4K, it's a square, hockey puck shape that measures 98 mm x 98 mm x 35 mm (3.9 in x 3.9 in x 1.4 in). It tips the scales at 425 g (15 oz), and the only indication that the Apple TV 4K is switched on is a little white light on the front. Neither of these 4K streamers are exactly ugly, but the Nvidia Shield 4K just edges it, we think.

Nvidia Shield 4K vs Apple TV 4K: features

Both these boxes have the same purpose in life: to serve up 4K video content as well as music, photos, games and other apps. Both come with an HDMI out connection, and both have a slim remote control (we just slightly prefer the one with the Apple TV 4K). The Nvidia Shield 4K comes with 16GB or a whopping 500GB of internal space, while the Apple TV 4K can be had with either 32GB or 64GB of internal storage on board.

The Apple TV 4K plays a smattering of games, mostly adapted from iOS, but the Nvidia Shield 4K is much more of a gaming machine (and has an optional gamepad accessory). You can stream games from the cloud via Nvidia GeForce Now (which needs an extra subscription), stream games from a PC on a local network (which doesn't), and access mobile games built for Android TV too. If you're at all interested in gaming, then you'll want to pick up the Nvidia Shield 4K.

Being an Android TV box, the Nvidia Shield 4K acts as a Chromecast too; the Apple TV 4K is compatible with AirPlay, meanwhile, so you can beam audio and video to it from an iPhone, iPad or Mac. Both boxes can double up as smart home hubs – the Apple TV 4K with Apple's HomeKit standard and the Nvidia Shield 4K via Google Assistant.

Nvidia Shield 4K vs Apple TV 4K: software

Software and app support is an important part of the equation here: the Nvidia Shield 4K comes with Android TV on board (complete with Google Assistant) while the Apple TV 4K comes with tvOS (complete with Siri). Both make use of an intuitive tiled interface that's simple to get around and gives you access to all your apps.

Most of the big names – Netflix, YouTube, Plex, Amazon Prime Video – are available on both platforms. As we've mentioned, the Nvidia Shield 4K is missing iTunes and Apple Music support, and the Apple TV 4K doesn't have Google Play Movies and TV. If you're more into your music, Spotify is on Android TV but not tvOS (though you can AirPlay tunes to the Apple TV 4K box from an iPhone).

The software comparison between the Nvidia Shield 4K and the Apple TV 4K is a lot like the Android vs iOS debate. Apple's box is a bit slicker in what it does, but it's also a bit more limited in terms of customisations and what you can do with apps and other devices that aren't made by Apple.

Nvidia Shield 4K vs Apple TV 4K: verdict

As is often the case when we're weighing up an Apple product, the Apple TV 4K is a fine choice if all of your other gear is made by Apple – it works seamlessly with iPhones and Macs, and with Apple HomeKit and Apple Music, and with videos available on iTunes, and with Apple Photos, and so on. Some third-party services are supported, like Netflix and Amazon Prime Video, but it's a very Apple-focused device.

The Nvidia Shield 4K isn't going to work as well with Apple stuff – it can't play videos from iTunes, for example. Overall though, it's the far more capable device, with support for external storage, and all the gaming extras you get courtesy of Nvidia, and the ability it has to act as a Plex server, and its native apps for the likes of Spotify and Google Play Movies & TV. You can even plug in a USB tuner and watch live TV.

So the choice here isn't really between the Nvidia Shield 4K or the Apple TV 4K: your choice is largely made depending on the devices you already own and the ecosystem you're already invested in. The Apple TV 4K is the best box for interfacing with other Apple stuff; for everything else, the Nvidia Shield 4K is the top choice."

https://www.t3.com/features/nvidia-shield-4k-tv-vs-apple-tv-4k

die-microcrap-die

TLDR: apple if you are already locked up in that garden and want something powerful but with nothing to utilize that power or a Shield if you appreciate customization, freedom, games, emulators!

Sabaton88

I just wish Android TV was more alive than it’s now basically shell for 10 apps.

PS. Article do not stress enough that Nvidia is superior gaming stream device, which could replace consoles

BiggussDikkuss

For USA owners that article is forgetting this service:

https://moviesanywhere.com/welcome

Really the choices are dependant on six things:

Do you need DolbyVision support and Atmos audio when streaming iTunes, VUDU or Netflix ?
Do you need working and correct color outputs when viewing mixed SDR / 4K HDR content with a variety of 4K HDR10 displays ?
Do you need high quality picture upscaling of all non 4K content ?
Do you need auto Frame Rate matching for smooth video playback for Apps like Netflix ?
Do you want to do some 4K games streaming ?
Do you need a full blown version of Kodi with Bluray quality Atmos audio passthrough.

For a 4K HDR10 media player the Shield currently has issues or simply lacks support for (1) thru (4)

But it does counter with (5) and (6).

And please Sideloading tablet Apps into a Shield, with subsequent remote control difficulties and ongoing Apps maintenance really is not "freedom or flexibility" when using the Shield. It's a PITA.

Native Apps are where it is at if you are going to compare platforms. Android TV Apps support is really quite a way behind the Apple tvOS equivalent, especially once you venture outside North America.

Also once you get outside the USA and have to deal with additional video Frame Rates of 25/50fps, the Apple TV 4K is the superior platform simply due to a lot more Apps supporting auto Frame Rate Matching functionality.

There is nothing worse than playing back 50fps content at 60Hz or having to manually fiddle and fart around on an Android TV platform to manually switch Video output when flipping between watching 24p Netflix and 25/50fps IPTV Apps content.

Connectivity - Shield wins.

Plug n Play and Polished with Worldwide support - Apple TV 4K wins.

DnB925Art

While the Shield TV or any other Android TV can't play videos from iTunes, it CAN play some movies via Movies Anywhere. Some movie purchases through iTunes can be played through apps on the Shield like Google Play Movies, Vudu, Movies Anywhere, and YouTube if they are on Movies Anywhere.

TotesMessenger

I'm a bot, bleep , bloop . Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:

[/r/shieldandroidtv] Nvidia Shield 4K vs Apple TV 4K: the best 4K boxes compared It's Android TV head to head against Apple TV

^(If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads.) ^( Info ^/ ^ Contact )

thnok

The strongest points such as the HDR and Dolby Vision/Atmos capabilities of both are missing.

KnifeFed

Does the Shield currently have any advantages over the Apple TV when it comes to (direct) playing 4K HEVC with HDR and Dolby Atmos/DTS:X from a Plex server?