I got a JBL Link Bar. Here are some of my observations so far.

by Limagyn

Sorry about the formatting. I'm on mobile. I'm switching from a Xiaomi Mi Box S that I got on sale around last holiday season. My experience with the Mi Box has been very lackluster, despite all the praise I saw it get on reviews. The performance was atrocious, CEC barely worked on it, there were a ton of bugs, and the remote was cheap, flimsy, and unresponsive. I could keep going but I digress. Needless to say, I've had a JBL Link sized hole in my living room for more than a year so I immediately pulled the trigger when it became available. I've been playing with it for about 4 hours now. Here are some things I've noticed:

Sound is good, but not $400 good. It's better than my TV's speakers so I'm not complaining. It's lacking on the low-end but I'm ok with that since I live in a townhome with thin walls. There are cheaper sound bars out there that perform just as well, if not better. Note, I do not plan on getting the subwoofer.

The performance is good. Moving around the OS is responsive but not super fluid. Android TV is known for being clunky and sluggish, but I like it nonetheless. The Link Bar is not as fast as the Nvidia Shield but it's not much slower either. I'm perfectly happy with it.

Switching through inputs with voice can be a bit clunky but it works. It recognizes the PS4 and the Nintendo Switch by name, but doesn't recognize the Xbox. Instead, you'd have to say "switch to HDMI 1" or something like that. Another note on this, if the command is going directly to the Link Bar or the remote, you don't have to specify the TV. If the command is going to a Google Home/mini/Nest Hub, than you'd have to say something like "switch to HDMI 1 on the living room TV"

I don't see any way to be able to set your own names to the HDMI inputs which is a bummer imo. I'm sure this can be fixed with a software update.

The Google Home app recognizes it as an Android TV device, not as a smart speaker. It doesn't let you pair it with a speaker group unfortunately. This has been causing issues for me as I have a Google Home mini and a regular Google Home in my living room. They can sync commands and music to each other but the Link Bar cannot. This has caused some weird overlap issues if all my devices hear a command at once. I know you can add a newer Chromecast to a speaker group but that doesn't seem possible with the Link Bar so far. I really hopes this feature gets added eventually.

CEC and ARC works great on it. The power button on the remote turns off the TV, not the Link Bar itself. That's a difference (but much appreciated change) in behavior over the Mi Box S, where the power button would turn off the TV and the Mi Box S itself.

If the TV is off and you turn it on while it's playing music, it'll cut off the music. It seems the Link Bar behaves as if it's a Google Home speaker when the TV is off but changes to behaving like an Android TV device when the TV is on. When it's on and you tell it to play music, it'll play it in the Android TV app. If you're on a different HDMI input, it'll go back to the Android TV page and start playing music there. If the TV is off, the music only plays from the sound bar in the same way a Google Home speaker would. Turning on the TV in this instance doesn't take you to the music app on Android TV.

Ethernet is only compatible with 10/100. No 1,000.

Switching to the input that has the PS4 automatically turns on that console. It doesn't do the same for the Switch or Xbox.

The performance on the mics is very impressive indeed. It can pick my voice up over a ton a noise, and even music coming from the sound bar itself at almost full volume.

I don't think this supports Stadia, and I don't know if it will at launch. I'm sure it will eventually though.

The service port on the back of the device is type-c. It's a small detail and I like it. The more type-c in my life, the better.

I'm still playing with it as I've only had it for a few hours. So far, I really like it, and the things I dislike about it can all be fixed with software updates. Supposedly all those come directly from Google for 3 years or so, so I'm hopeful.

WazWaz

Thanks for report!

Check if nicknames can be set in Google Home, that's how other devices work. Tell us!

Bodycount9

You mentioned that it has 10/100 ethernet. You dont need gigabit ethernet to a media player until you start watching 8k broadcasts. 4k is perfectly fine with 100 meg.

And it's odd you have so many problems with your mi box. I have two and dont see any of the issues you see. Both are working great and it was the best $120 I spent 2.5 years ago since it already paid for itself from cable box lease fees many times over. I was paying $34 a month just in lease fees when I had cable TV.

clarkss12

Nice!!

Heaney555

This is going to sound like a really odd question: can you use this but set the TV to use the TV speakers (not JBL), so that it just acts as an Android TV device and then a speaker when the TV is off ?

midnitte

A shame to hear about the sound grouping, and other music problems.

How's voice recognition over content playing?

I hope more companies move this route, I'd really like an Android TV soundbar that can pick up commands - a Google home doesn't really work well when the TV next to it is on...

TomEnom

So far, I really like it, and the things I dislike about it can all be fixed with software updates. Supposedly all those come directly from Google for 3 years or so, so I'm hopeful.

This is a key detail, and yet it is rarely addressed in reviews or anywhere for that matter. Would be interested in some confirmation of that.

I think we have learned by now that, if updates are at the discretion of the manufacturer, they will stop as soon as they are no longer pushing this product.

TehJonny

Do we know if this supports YouTube HDR? as well as EAC3 Audio?

Any colorspace issues on this device also like what the nvidia shield has... i.e some TV's can cause red to look orang-ish?

BiggussDikkuss

CEC and ARC works great on it. The power button on the remote turns off the TV, not the Link Bar itself. That's a difference (but much appreciated change) in behavior over the Mi Box S, where the power button would turn off the TV and the Mi Box S itself.

LOL, complaining about HDMI CEC on anything is like complaining about a sexually transmitted disease after random unprotected sex. ie. it’s a complete lottery if you end up with something nasty or not !

What will work for one persons specific setup will be a complete disaster for someone else due to mainly TV manufacturers not adhering to any sort of standard.

shagnscooby

How's the sound compared to the regular Google Home?

GazaIan

Switching to the input that has the PS4 automatically turns on that console. It doesn't do the same for the Switch or Xbox.

That's a CEC feature, no idea why it doesn't work on your Switch but Xbox still doesn't support CEC.

JoinTheBattle

Thanks for this! Happy Cake Day!

JoinTheBattle

Would be really cool if you could use Google Cast/Google Home speakers as rear surround speakers, similar to a Sonos system. Granted, getting speaker grouping working at all is a much bigger priority.

Nahianc

No gigabit Ethernet? That's disappointing.